Kosovo specialist chambers rules of procedure and evidence. United nations international tribunal for the prosecution. Secondary victimisation protection of the victims rights. Rules of procedure and evidence adopted on 11 february 1994 as amended 5 may 1994 as further amended 4 october 1994 as amended 30 january 1995 as amended 3 may 1995 as further amended 15 june 1995 as amended 6 october 1995 as further amended 18 january 1996 as amended 23 april 1996 as amended 25 june and 5 july 1996. These rules of procedure and evidence, adopted pursuant to article 28 of the statute of the special tribunal for lebanon, shall enter into force on 20 march 2009. The appeals chamber in katanga and chui ruled that rule 814 of the rules of procedure and evidence should be read to include the words persons at risk on account of the activities of the court so as to reflect the intention of the states that adopted the rome statute and the rules of procedure and evidence, as expressed in article 543f. The foregoing amendment to the federal rules of evidence shall take effect on december 1, 2019, and shall govern in all proceedings thereafter commenced and, insofar as just and practicable, all proceedings then pending. The rules of procedure and evidence of the icty leiden. Together these rules established a legal aid system for the tribunal. The rulemaking power of the judges of the ictr and icty, south african journal of human rights vol 18, no 4, 2002, p 570. These rules of procedure and evidence, adopted pursuant to article 15 of the statute of the tribunal, shall come into force on 14 march 1994. Rule 694 of the icc rules of procedure and evidence rules directs judges to admit evidence, taking into account, inter alia, the probative value of the evidence and any prejudice that such evidence may cause to a fair trial or to a fair evaluation of the testimony of a witness. Rules of procedure and evidence international criminal court.
Requests for amendment of these irs may be made to the rules and procedure committee by a judge, a coinvestigating judge, a coprosecutor, the head of. Creating laws of evidence for international criminal law. The evidence submitted by the prosecutor provides reasonable grounds to believe that between 5000 to 7000 members of the croatian army hv, as well as some members of the croatian armed forces hos, were present in the territory of bosnia and were involved, both directly and through their relations with hb and the hvo, in clashes with. The foregoing amendment to the federal rules of evidence shall take effect on december 1, 2019, and shall govern in all proceedings thereafter commenced and, insofar as. The rules of procedure and evidence of the international criminal court do not affect the procedural rules for any national court or legal system for the purpose of national proceedings.
Richard may and marieke wierda, international criminal evidence ardsley, new york. Practice direction on procedure for the proposal, consideration of and publication of amendments to the rules of procedure and evidence of the international tribunal, it143rev. Rule 11bis of the icty rules of procedure and evidence rope 3 provided the conditions for transfers, which included that the receiving country had an adequate legal framework that foresaw criminal responsibility and an. Entry into force these rules of procedure and evidence, adopted pursuant to article 14 of the statute of the tribunal, shall come into force on 29 june 1995. Rules of procedure and evidence should be read in conjunction with and subject to the provisions of the statute. Rules of procedure and evidence international criminal.
The rules of evidence are broadly similar in all three judicial organs, as the ictr on its establishment adopted the rules of procedure and evidence from the icty as they were at the time. Essays on icty procedure and evidence in honour of. In addition to cases to which rule 11, rule, rule 59 or rule 61 applies, where a trial chamber or a permanent judge is satisfied that a. However after the first year the first icty judges had drafted and adopted all the rules. Practice direction on procedure for the implementation of rule 92bisb of the rules of procedure and evidence. Human rights watch wants to see officials of the former iraqi government responsible for serious human rights crimes brought to justice.
These rules of procedure and evidence, adopted pursuant to article 14 of the statute of the tribunal, shall come into force on 29 june l995. Ntanda nsereko, rules of procedure and evidence of the. In the rules, unless the context otherwise requires, the following terms shall mean. The purpose of this article is to analyse developments in the rules of procedure and evidence of the international criminal tribunal for the former yugoslavia icty. Development of the flexibility principle 263 gideon boas 22. Requests for amendment of these irs may be made to the rules and procedure committee by a judge, a coinvestigating judge, a coprosecutor, the head of the defence support section. The case law database cld is a gateway to the jurisprudence of the ictr, icty, and irmct appeals chambers it provides direct access to extracts of key judgements and decisions rendered by the ictr, icty, and irmct appeals chambers since their inception, as well as to fulltext versions of the corresponding appeal judgements and decisions. Icty rules of procedure and evidence, rules 62bis, 62ter permitting both guilty pleas and plea agreements, although plea agreements have been preferred in practice. The federal rules of evidence are amended to include an amendment to rule 807. Evidence of an accused ictrictyirmct case law database. Developments in the law of procedure and evidence at the international criminal tribunal for the former yugoslavia and the international criminal court. Rules of procedure and evidence of the residual special court for sierra leone. Notice of appeal a subject to subrule b, a party seeking to appeal a judgement or sentence shall, not more than thirty days from the date on which the judgement or sentence was. Rules on evidence cover an extensive part of the two.
In accordance with article 15 of its statute, the international criminal tribunal for the former yugoslavia icty adopted its rules of procedure and evidence on 11 february 1994. In general, the outbreak of civil war in the former yugoslavia was precipitated. Rules of procedure and evidence global policy forum. Rules of evidence and procedure for the international. International tribunal in accordance with the present statute and the rules of procedure and evidence of the international tribunal. Rule 2 definitions a in the rules, unless the context otherwise requires, the following terms shall mean. Such protection measures shall include, but shall not be limited to, the conduct of in camera proceedings and the protection of the. Pdf noting remarks of sam lowery, trial lawyer in the of fice of the. The icty has drawn attention to the fact that evidence given in this manner may detract from the reliance placed upon his or her evidence, while noting that it is a matter for the assessment of. This document is reflected in rule 6c of the rules, and lays out the procedures to be followed for proposal and amendment to the rules. International criminal tribunal for rwanda, rules of.
On the international level, procedure is substance. Criminal tribunal for the former yugoslavia icty, whose rules served as a model for. The appeals chamber restated the applicable law with respect to the admissibility of the additional evidence on appeal. But note that defence counsel do have direct representation on the rules committee of the icty. As the icty is part of the united nations and as it was the first international court for criminal justice, the development of a juridical infrastructure was considered quite a challenge. The newly adopted rules of procedure and evidence of the iraqi special tribunal are lacking several important fair trial protections. Written by academics and practitioners, and notably many insiders at the icty, this volume focuses particularly on the international and criminal law developments that have taken place in the practice and procedure of the tribunal. Legacy website of the international criminal tribunal for rwanda. The rules of procedure and evidence of the icty leiden journal. Extensive powers of arrest have been provided expressis verbis in the ictys rules of procedure and evidence, and few objections based ahead. Definitions amended 29 may 2004 a in the rules, unless the context otherwise requires, the following terms shall mean.
Evidence before the icty 249 richard may and marieke wierda 21. Bar association icty caselaw indictments an indictment may also be defective when the material facts are pleaded without sufficient specificity, such as, unless there are special circumstances, when the times refer to broad date ranges, the places are only generally indicated, and the victims are only generally identified. Definitions adopted 11 feb 1994 a in the rules, unless the context otherwise requires, the following terms shall mean. Developments in the law of procedure and evidence at the. The reaction of a commonlaw commentator to this rule was quite predictable, it is hoped that this provision will not be interpreted as a license for judges to descend pellmell into the area of trial combat. Rules of evidence in cases of sexual assault rule 97. Further, according to rule 115 of the rules of procedure and evidence of the tribunal rules, for additional evidence to be admissible on appeal, the following requirements must be met. In accordance with article 15 of its statute, the international criminal tribunal for the former yugoslavia icty adopted its rules of procedure and evidence on. The icc drafters also incorporated many aspects of the ad hoc tribunals rules. Ensuring the effective prosecution of sexually violent crimes in the. Special tribunal for lebanon swiftly adopts its rules of. International criminal procedure, edited by two insiders to international criminal proceedings, professor linda carter and professor fausto pocar, a judge at the icty and a former president of this tribunal, is.
Further, according to rule 115 of the rules of procedure and evidence of the tribunal rules, for additional evidence to be admissible on appeal, the. The otp did not refer to rape as direct evidence of another war crime, such. Robinsons observations on the hybrid nature of the rules of procedure and evidence of the international criminal tribunal for the former yugoslavia. Comparing the rules of evidence applicable before the icty. Intl criminal court icc, rules of procedure and evidence, rule. In a recent article, i discussed how the rules of procedure and evidence of the icty amount to the first coherent body of principles governing the prosecution of violations of. Admissibility of evidence under the rules of procedure and evidence of the icty. These rules of procedure and evidence as first amended on 7 march 2003, are applicable pursuant to article 14 of the statute of the special court for sierra leone, and entered into force on 12 april 2002. A person against whom one or more counts in an indictment. The abiding problem of witness statements in international criminal. Just because the bosnian war crimes chamber is inheriting the ictys cases. Irs shall be submitted to the rules and procedure committee as soon as possible.
Procedural due process and the prosecution of genocide. Administrative office of the courts 511 union street, suite 600 nashville, tn 37219. In all cases, the rules of procedure and evidence should be read in conjunction with and subject to the provisions of the statute. Sierra leone special court rules of procedure and evidence, rule 62. International criminal procedure download ebook pdf, epub. The judges of the international tribunal shall adopt rules of procedure and evidence for the conduct of the pretrial phase of the proceedings, trials and appeals, the admission of evidence, the protection of victims and witnesses and other appropriate matters. Rule 2 definitions adopted 11 feb 1994 a in the rules, unless the context otherwise requires, the following terms shall mean. The rules of procedure and evidence of the international criminal court do not affect the procedural rules for any national court or legal system for the purpose of national. The rules of procedure and evidence of the icty are the first coherent body of principles governing the prosecution of violations of international humanitarian law, or indeed international law, to be constructed. Rules of procedure and evidence of the international criminal tribunal for the former yugoslavia. The icty statute, 4 together with the rules of procedure and evidence rules, 5 provide only general guidelines as to what factors should be taken into account in sentencing considerations. This major reference work identifies and crystallizes the common rules and principles underlying international criminal procedure, as developed by international courts and tribunals since the second world war. Essays on icty procedure and evidence in honour of gabrielle. Remoral of incapacity to tstity from crime or mteresr 3.
International criminal law developments in the case law of. International criminal tribunal for the former yugoslavia. Practice direction on procedure for the proposal, consideration of and publication of amendments to the rules of procedure and evidence of the international tribunal, it143, 18 december 1999. Definitions a in the rules, unless the context otherwise requires, the following terms shall mean. Ictr rules of procedure and evidence, rules 62, 62b. The rules of procedure and evidence that govern proceedings in the trial chambers shall apply mutatis mutandis to proceedings in the appeals chamber.
455 1288 241 708 1462 622 1378 698 482 1460 1333 1469 1313 1531 210 464 1489 872 1563 793 514 1364 945 298 1169 855 968 813 929 1283 1233 1259 538 854 715 337 1338